Session Seven · Unit Three — The Building and the City
The Building’s Biography — The Researched and Braided Essay
The Genre: The Researched & Braided Essay
Handouts & Worksheets
Main Points of the Lesson
- Research is a form of attention. Facts are not the enemy of the personal essay; they are its ballast. A date, a name, a blueprint can anchor a memory.
- Primary and secondary sources. A 1939 photograph or a finding aid is a primary source; a website history is secondary. Know which you are using, and say so.
- The braided essay. Two or three strands — a personal story, a public history, an object or idea — alternate and illuminate one another without being forced together.
- Our building’s strands. According to the Penn Architectural Archives, 2601 was built between 1931 and 1939 by Cret and Colish, associated architects; the building’s own history places it on land once used by the Baldwin Locomotive Works. Each fact is a strand waiting for a life.
- Check everything. Every fact in a published essay must be verifiable. When sources disagree, say that they disagree.
Reading for Class — Click to Open
- University of Pennsylvania Architectural Archives, Aaron Colish Finding Aid — including the 2601 Parkway Apartments — read the Penn finding aid (PDF)
A primary-source guide: photographs, brochures, and floor plans from the building’s first years. - 2601 Parkway Condominium Association, History of 2601 Parkway — reread the building’s history page
Compare its account with the finding aid. Where do they agree? Where do they differ? - The Brevity Blog, “Braids: A Braided Essay About Braids & Braided Essays” — read at the Brevity Blog
A braided essay that teaches the form by performing it. - Textbook: Tell It Slant, Chapter 7, “Glorious Facts: Research and the Research Essay” — see the textbook guide
After Our Discussion — Critical Reception
- Baldwin Locomotive Works — history (Wikipedia) — The Philadelphia industrial giant associated with the site’s history.
- W. E. B. Du Bois, The Philadelphia Negro (Encyclopedia of Greater Philadelphia) — The 1899 study that made a Philadelphia neighborhood a subject of research — a model of documentary nonfiction about a place.
In-Class Writing Prompt — Laptops Closed
Draw three columns. Label them Me, The Building, and The World. Under each, list five dates or moments — your life, 2601’s history (1939 opening, the lobby mural, the 2020 green roof), and world events. Draw lines where they touch. Then write one page alternating between two columns, a paragraph at a time.
Bring the timeline home; it is the skeleton of your braided essay.
What happens with this: nothing is collected. It is yours, written on paper, in your notebook. No one is asked to read aloud who does not wish to.
Discussion Questions
- What is the difference between a history of a building and a biography of one?
- The building’s history page and the Penn finding aid tell overlapping stories. Where do they differ, and how should an essayist handle the difference?
- In “Braids,” how does each strand change the meaning of the others?
- Whose lives are missing from the official record of a building like ours — staff, workers, earlier residents? How could nonfiction restore them?
Homework
- Read Tell It Slant, Chapter 6, “Writing the Arts.”
- Write a braided essay of 1,000–1,500 words weaving your life with the history of 2601 or of Philadelphia. Include a short list of your sources.
- Read for Session 8: Rainer Maria Rilke, Auguste Rodin (first part). Look closely at the lobby mural on your way in.
Where This Can Go
Where a researched essay about 2601 can go: Hidden City Philadelphia (architecture and urban history), Broad Street Review, and literary journals such as River Teeth and Fourth Genre. A braided essay about this building is one of the best pieces this course can produce.
Before Next Time — Session 8
Across the Parkway — Writing the Arts. The lobby mural, the Rodin Museum, the Art Museum steps: learning to write about art without explaining it away.