Handouts & Worksheets
Main Points of the Lesson
- A building has a life. Writers who tell the story of a building treat it as a character with a lifespan: a plan, an opening, good years and hard ones, renovations, arrivals and departures, a present. The shape of a biography is ready-made.
- Three ways in. The building as protagonist: architects, owners, construction, change (Hidden City Philadelphia, Archiveadelphia). The residents as chorus: many lives, one address (the Tenement Museum’s 97 Orchard Street; Ben Austen’s High-Risers, part oral history). The writer as guide: one person climbing through the rooms with us (Joseph Mitchell’s “Up in the Old Hotel”).
- Numbers can be a chorus. The Tenement Museum says 97 Orchard Street was home to “an estimated 7,000 people from over 20 nations.” A single statistic can hold a crowd; the writer’s task is to let a few of those people step forward.
- Buildings learn. Stewart Brand argues that “buildings perform best when they can evolve over decades.” The changes residents make — a new roof garden, a converted room, a restored mural — are part of the story, not interruptions to it.
- Our building’s biography has begun. Archiveadelphia’s “The Tiles and Tribulations of 2601 Parkway” tells the site’s passage from a Baldwin Locomotive Works roundhouse to Cret’s apartment house and its lobby mural. What it cannot supply is what the people in this room know: what it has been like to live here.
Reading for Class — Click to Open
- Tenement Museum, “97 Orchard Street” — read at the Tenement Museum
A five-story Lower East Side tenement, 22 apartments of three rooms each, and the thousands of lives that passed through it between 1863 and 1935. - Hidden City Philadelphia, “St. James the Greatest” — read at Hidden City
The life of a Philadelphia luxury apartment house at 13th and Walnut — and, in the comments, the memories of people who worked and lived there. - Archiveadelphia, “The Tiles and Tribulations of 2601 Parkway” — read at Archiveadelphia
Our own building’s story, drawn from archives, newspapers, and historians. - Textbook: Tell It Slant, Chapter 4, “Gathering the Threads of History”; Chapter 7, “Glorious Facts: Research and the Research Essay” — see the textbook guide
After Our Discussion — Critical Reception
- Janet Malcolm, “The Master Writer of the City” (New York Review of Books, 2015) — On Joseph Mitchell’s “Up in the Old Hotel,” in which a restaurant owner and a reporter ride a hand-operated elevator into a building’s abandoned upper floors.
- “Up in the New Old Hotel” (New York Times, 2008) — A return visit to the Fulton Ferry Hotel building Mitchell made famous.
- Inside the Dream Palace: Sherill Tippins on the Chelsea Hotel (Los Angeles Times) — A whole book built as the biography of one building and its residents.
- Ben Austen, High-Risers (Kirkus Reviews) — Chicago’s Cabrini-Green told through residents’ voices as well as history.
- “Artist Explores Urban Renewal at Park Towne Place” (Hidden City Philadelphia) — The Parkway’s other apartment towers, a few blocks from us, and the neighborhood they replaced.
- Stewart Brand, How Buildings Learn (BBC series, via Open Culture) — Six free episodes on how buildings change with the people who use them.
In-Class Writing Prompt — Laptops Closed
Fifteen minutes. You may write in the third person, or let the building speak as “I.” Mark anything you would need to verify later.
What happens with this: nothing is collected. It is yours, written on paper, in your notebook. No one is asked to read aloud who does not wish to.
Discussion Questions
- The Tenement Museum tells one building’s story through thousands of people; Mitchell tells one building’s story through one man and one staircase. Which approach suits 2601 better, and why?
- In “St. James the Greatest,” readers’ comments add memories the article lacks. What does that suggest about who owns a building’s history?
- What does Archiveadelphia’s account of 2601 leave out that only residents could supply?
- If someone wrote the biography of this building fifty years from now, what should they know about the people living here today?
Homework
- Read Tell It Slant, Chapter 13, “The Writing Process and Revision.”
- Choose the one piece from the course you most want to carry forward — the essay you will revise and send out after the course. Bring a clean, printed copy to Session 11.
- Read for Session 11: Montaigne, “Of Repentance,” and our course page Sending Your Work Out.
Where This Can Go
Where a building story can go: Hidden City Philadelphia (by pitch to its editorial director) and Broad Street Review. A building biography of 2601, told by many residents, is exactly the kind of project a follow-up course could take up — if the class decides it wants one. Keep these pages in your 2601 folder.
Before Next Time — Session 11
The Roof Garden — Revision and Choosing a Home. Montaigne, the one essay you carry forward, a revision plan you can follow on your own, and a first map of where true stories are published.