Main Points of the Lesson
- Memoir is a slice, not a life. Autobiography tells a life; memoir chooses one strand of it — a season, a relationship, a question — and follows that strand faithfully.
- The double voice. Every memoir has two narrators: the younger self who experienced the events and the older self who understands them. The music of memoir is the conversation between them.
- Scene and summary. Scene slows time and puts the reader in the room; summary moves us across years. Memoir needs both, and the writer must decide which moments earn a scene.
- Memory is a floor plan. Drawing the rooms of a remembered house unlocks sensory detail that direct recall cannot reach. Place holds memory.
- Franklin’s arrival. Franklin walks up Market Street in 1723 with three puffy rolls, one under each arm, eating the third, while his future wife watches from a doorway. It is Philadelphia’s most famous arrival scene — and a lesson in self-portraiture with irony.
Reading for Class — Click to Open
- Benjamin Franklin, The Autobiography of Benjamin Franklin — opening through the arrival in Philadelphia — read on Project Gutenberg
Read from the beginning through Franklin’s first morning in Philadelphia. Watch the older Franklin smiling at the younger one. - Textbook: Tell It Slant, Chapter 1, “The Body of Memory”; Chapter 2, “Writing the Family” — see the textbook guide
After Our Discussion — Critical Reception
- The Autobiography of Benjamin Franklin — composition and influence (Wikipedia) — How an unfinished private memoir became a founding American text.
- Memoir — the form and its history (Wikipedia) — Distinctions among memoir, autobiography, and personal essay.
In-Class Writing Prompt — Laptops Closed
The floor plan stays in your notebook. The switch of tense and voice is the exercise; notice what the older voice knows that the younger one did not.
What happens with this: nothing is collected. It is yours, written on paper, in your notebook. No one is asked to read aloud who does not wish to.
Discussion Questions
- Where do you hear the older Franklin commenting on the younger one? What is the tone of that commentary?
- Franklin calls his mistakes “errata,” a printer’s word. What does that metaphor reveal about how he sees a life?
- What does Franklin choose to dramatize as scene, and what does he summarize? Why?
- Is a memoirist obligated to tell the whole truth, or only nothing but the truth?
Homework
- Read Tell It Slant, Chapter 9, “Innovative Forms: The Wide Variety of Creative Nonfiction.”
- Write a memoir scene of 750–1,000 words from your floor plan, using both voices: the one who lived it and the one who remembers.
- Read for Session 4: Brian Doyle, “Joyas Voladoras,” and the Brevity craft essay “Consider the Platypus.”
Where This Can Go
Where a memoir scene can go: Narratively’s The Personals, Hippocampus, and — for writers over fifty or sixty — Passager and Persimmon Tree. Consider a companion scene: your first night at 2601. What did the apartment sound like before it was yours?
Before Next Time — Session 4
The Elevator — Flash Nonfiction and the Lyric Essay. Thirteen floors, thirteen fragments. We learn compression, white space, and the lyric essay’s logic of image and association.